S-corps · 13 min read · Updated Oct 2026

OnPay Review (2026): Price, Tax Filings and OnPay vs. Gusto

$55
a month to pay just you, in any number of states
2 or 4 days
from running payroll to payday, set by a risk review
4.8/5
from 469 reviews on Capterra (Sept 2026)

The short answer

Your S-corpA tax status a business can elect. You pay yourself a salary through payroll, and profit above it skips Social Security and Medicare tax. election came through, or your first hire is a few months off, and you’re comparing payroll services. OnPay comes up because it costs the same as Gusto Solo to pay just you, and its price doesn’t change when payroll runs in a second state. This OnPay review covers what it costs in 2026, what it files for you, when the money leaves your account and where it trails Gusto.

Is OnPay good for a one-person S-corp?

Yes, especially if you may hire or work in more than one state: it’s $55 a month to pay just yourself, with federal, state and local filings included. That matches Gusto Solo, and extra states cost nothing more. It doesn’t file your S-corp election or suggest a salary, and some recent reviews say support is slow to fix mistakes.

Our take: OnPay is the pick for a one-person S-corp that expects to hire, or that runs payroll in more than one state, which on Gusto means the $92 Plus plan. If you’ll stay solo in one state and price matters most, Patriot Full Service is $13 a month less, as our Patriot Payroll review explains. If you’re still setting up the S-corp, our Gusto review covers the election help and salary suggestion that Gusto Solo adds.

What OnPay costs

OnPay sells one payroll plan, Payroll Essentials, with every payroll feature included. Here’s what it costs when you’re the only person on payroll.

Payroll Essentials
Price a month$49 + $6 a person paid
For just you$55
A month with no payroll$49
Federal, state and local filingsIncluded
Extra statesIncluded
Extra or canceled pay runsIncluded
Year-end forms by mail$10 a form, or print them free
Penalty guaranteeYes, for OnPay’s errors
From OnPay’s pricing page and help center, October 25, 2026. Sales tax is added in many states.

The first month is free. After that, OnPay bills monthly, on the 1st or the 15th, and the $6 covers only the people paid in the month before, so the bill after a month with no payroll is $49. There are no setup fees or discounts, and an HR add-on is $15 a month plus $2 a person, which a company of one rarely needs.

Paying just you · one state or two · October 2026

What a year of payroll costs

OnPayOther services
Patriot, 1 state$504
Patriot, 2 states$648
OnPay, 1 or 2 states$660
Gusto Solo, 1 state$660
Gusto Plus, 2 states$1,104

Monthly base fee plus one person paid, times 12, before intro offers. Patriot means Full Service, and Gusto Solo covers one state, so a second state means Gusto Plus. From each company’s pricing page, October 25, 2026.

In one state, OnPay and Gusto Solo cost the same, and Patriot Full Service is $156 a year less. A second state narrows the gap: Patriot adds $12 a month, Gusto moves you to its Plus plan at $92, and OnPay stays at $55. That can come up if you live in one state and work in another, or move partway through the year.

What OnPay files and pays for you

OnPay is full-service payroll: it figures the taxes on each paycheck, takes them from your business account, and pays and files them for you. Here’s what that covers.

  • Federal returns: Form 941 every quarter, Form 940 every year, and your W-2 with the W-3 that goes with it. OnPay also makes each tax deposit with the IRS on your schedule, and files 1099s for contractors you pay through it.
  • State and local taxes: state income tax withholding, state unemployment tax and paid family leave where your state has it, plus any city, county or township payroll tax. When an address or worksite brings in a local tax, OnPay adds it and tells you what it needs.
  • Quarters with no payroll: if you pay yourself once a year, OnPay still files the zero returns, which the IRS expects every quarter once you’ve filed your first Form 941The quarterly payroll tax return. A payroll service files it for you..
  • Copies for your records: every return it files stays in your account under Filings, even after you leave OnPay. They’re copies, so you don’t send them anywhere.

OnPay’s Tax Accuracy Guarantee pays the penalties and interest caused by its own errors. It doesn’t cover mistakes that come from wrong IDs or rates you entered, or from information OnPay asked for and never got.

What you need to set it up

OnPay’s team sets up the account with you, and its onboarding checklist lists what to have ready. For a one-person S-corp, that’s:

  • Your tax ID numbers: the company’s EINEmployer Identification Number: your business’s tax ID, like a Social Security number for the business. Free from the IRS., your state withholding ID and your state unemployment (SUTAState unemployment tax, charged on each worker's wages up to a yearly limit the state sets. New employers get an account number and a tax rate from the state.) account number and rate, plus any local tax IDs. Your state sends the SUTA number and rate when you register as an employer.
  • Form 8655The IRS form that names a payroll company as your reporting agent, so it can file your payroll tax returns and make your deposits. You stay responsible for the tax.: OnPay fills it in at step three of setup, and you pick your title and sign. It’s the IRS form that lets OnPay file and deposit for you, and without it OnPay can’t enroll the company in EFTPSThe Electronic Federal Tax Payment System, the Treasury's free website for business tax payments, including payroll tax deposits. Individuals can no longer open new accounts. or call the IRS for you.
  • State access: some states also need you to give OnPay third-party administrator access to your state tax account, or sign a power of attorneyA signed form that lets someone else, like a tax pro or a payroll company, deal with a tax agency for you. For the IRS, it's Form 2848., in each state where you pay someone.
  • A business bank account: the account payroll comes out of, verified with small test transactions or through Plaid. Here’s how to open one.
  • Your own details: your ID and contact information as the owner, including a direct phone number, plus your W-4, salary and pay schedule.
  • This year’s payroll so far: if another service already paid you this year, OnPay’s team enters that payroll for you so the year-end forms add up.

OnPay’s terms ask for the signed setup documents, including any state powers of attorney, at least 10 business days before your first payroll. One job stays with you after setup: when your state sends a new unemployment rate, usually for January 1 or July 1, you enter it in OnPay.

When the money leaves your account

OnPay takes the whole payroll, your net pay and the taxes, from the business account in one draft, the business day after you submit it. How far ahead you submit depends on a risk review its ACHThe U.S. network for bank-to-bank transfers. A client paying your invoice by ACH usually costs you 1% or less, versus about 3% by card. team runs after you verify your bank account.

  • 2-day turnaround: submit payroll by 11:30 p.m. Eastern on Wednesday. The money leaves Thursday, and your pay lands Friday morning.
  • 4-day turnaround: submit by 11:30 p.m. Eastern on Monday. The money leaves Tuesday, and your pay lands Friday morning.
  • Wire only: OnPay can ask some companies, mostly ones with very large payrolls, to wire the money instead. Not every company is approved for direct deposit.

Here’s what that looks like. Say you pay yourself $5,000 on a Friday with a 2-day turnaround. You submit on Wednesday, and on Thursday at least $5,382.50 leaves the business account: your $5,000 of pay plus the company’s $382.50 share of Social Security and Medicare, and any unemployment tax due on the paycheck.

Your own share of those taxes and your income tax withholding come out of the $5,000. OnPay holds the tax money and deposits it with the IRS and your state when each deposit is due.

Weekends and bank holidays don’t count as business days, so they push the dates back. You can submit a payroll up to 31 days early, and cancel it free until 11:30 p.m. the business day before the draft. If your turnaround doesn’t fit, you can ask OnPay about other options, and it may review the approval again after 6 months.

What it does for an S-corp, and what it doesn’t

OnPay has a page just for S-corp owners, and it covers the payroll side of running one.

  • Pay yourself on your schedule. Monthly, quarterly or once a year, with unlimited pay runs at no extra cost.
  • Your health insurance. If the S-corp pays your health insurance premiums or puts money in your HSAHealth savings account: money goes in tax-free, grows tax-free, and comes out tax-free for medical costs., OnPay’s shareholder pay types add the amounts to your W-2The form an employer sends each January showing your wages and the tax withheld. As an S-corp owner, your own company sends you one. wages for income tax only. They have to run through payroll by December 31, and to have income tax withheld on them, you run them with a regular paycheck. Here’s how S-corp health insurance works.
  • Contractors in the same place. You can pay 1099 contractors through OnPay too, and it files their 1099s after the year ends.
  • No S-corp election help. OnPay doesn’t prepare Form 2553The IRS form you file to elect S-corp tax status., so you file the election yourself. Here’s how the election works.
  • No salary tool. There’s no reasonable-salary calculator. Ours is free, and our guide to setting a reasonable salary covers what the IRS looks at.
  • Payroll only. It doesn’t file the S-corp’s own return, Form 1120-S, or keep your books, though it syncs payroll to QuickBooks and Xero.

What its users say

OnPay rates 4.8 out of 5 from 469 reviews on Capterra, as of September 29, 2026. On Trustpilot it’s 3.6 from 318, even though 84% of those reviews are five stars and 11% are one star. Trustpilot’s score gives more weight to recent reviews, and only 48 came in over the past year.

Trustpilot also notes that OnPay hasn’t invited customers to leave reviews lately, so its reviews “may not be representative.” OnPay has replied to 80% of the negative ones, usually within 48 hours.

To see past the averages, we read the 20 most recent five-star and the 20 most recent one-star reviews on Trustpilot. Here’s what came up most.

  • Praise: of the 20 five-star reviews, from February to October 2026, 12 praised the support team and 12 said it’s easy to use. Seven mentioned help with setup, and 6 the price.
  • Complaints: the 20 one-star reviews go back to January 2025. The biggest group, 6, said support was slow or didn’t fix the problem, and 2 more said a corrected W-2 took months. Three were about canceling or billing, 3 said OnPay closed or turned down their account, 2 had trouble with setup and 2 said it didn’t fit their business. One said a state filing was late, and one came from an employee.

Support is the theme on both sides: more than half of the five-star reviews praise the support team, and the biggest group of one-star reviews is about a fix that took too long. On Capterra, a self-employed reviewer who used the free trial wrote in December 2025 that they wished they could “make the date of check closer” to the day they ran payroll, which is the turnaround at work.

Where it falls short

No payroll service is perfect. These are the trade-offs worth knowing, starting with where OnPay trails Gusto.

  • No hand-holding for a new S-corp. There’s no election help and no salary suggestion, and Gusto Solo includes both at the same price.
  • A risk review sets your payday. You won’t know whether payroll is due 2 or 4 business days ahead until OnPay’s ACH team reviews your account, and it may review that again only after 6 months, if you ask.
  • Slow fixes. The biggest group of recent one-star reviews describes corrections, including corrected W-2s, that took weeks or months.
  • Weekday support only. Phone, chat and email support is U.S.-based and open 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern, Monday to Friday.
  • Unemployment rates are yours to update. When your state changes your rate, you enter the new one.
  • Account reviews. OnPay’s terms let it turn down a company whose credit, or its owners’ credit, it can’t verify, and 3 of 20 recent one-star reviews said an account was closed or turned down.
  • 30 days’ notice to leave. Its terms ask for 30 days’ written notice to end the service.

OnPay vs. the alternatives

Here’s how OnPay lines up against the payroll services a one-person S-corp weighs it against most.

ServicePrice for just youBest for
OnPay$55 a month, in any number of statesOwners who may hire, or who pay themselves in more than one state
Gusto Solo$55 a month, in one stateNew S-corps that want election help and a salary suggestion
Patriot Full Service$42 a month, plus $12 for each extra stateThe lowest price that still files your taxes
Square Payroll$41 a monthOwners who already take payments with Square
Regular prices for one person paid, checked October 25, 2026, before intro offers.

OnPay or Gusto?

For one person in one state, they cost the same, so the choice comes down to what you want help with. Gusto Solo walks you through the S-corp election and suggests a salary, which matters most in your first year as an S-corp. OnPay stays at $55 in a second state, where Gusto needs its $92 Plus plan, and in one state both charge $6 a month for each person you add.

Our full payroll comparison adds Roll by ADP, Wave and QuickBooks, and our Gusto review and Patriot Payroll review go through those two in detail.

Who OnPay fits

Our take, based on what it does well and where it falls short:

  • A good fit if your S-corp election is done, your salary is set, and you expect to hire, run payroll in more than one state or owe a local payroll tax.
  • Also a fit if you’d rather have OnPay’s team set up the account and enter this year’s payroll for you.
  • Less of a fit if you’re still setting up the S-corp and want help with the election and salary, or if you’ll stay solo in one state and want the lowest price.
  • Not needed if you’re a sole proprietor or an LLC taxed the default way. You pay yourself with an owner’s drawMoney you move from your business to yourself as a sole proprietor or LLC owner. It isn’t a business expense and isn’t taxed separately., not payroll. Here’s how paying yourself works. OnPay can still pay employees, including your own kids. Here’s how hiring your kids works.

If it fits, OnPay’s site has the current offer, including the free first month.

How to sign up, switch or cancel

  • Sign up. You share a few details about the business, and OnPay’s team sets up the account and enters your information with you. The first month is free, and its terms ask for the signed setup documents at least 10 business days before your first payroll.
  • Switch mid-year. OnPay’s team enters the payroll you’ve already run this year. If you switch mid-quarter, OnPay asks you to tell your current provider not to file that quarter’s unemployment taxes, because OnPay will. A switch at the start of a quarter keeps each quarter’s Form 941 with one service.
  • Fix a payroll. Until the money is drafted, you can delete a pay run, correct it and run it again at no cost. After that, pay already deposited can’t be pulled back, and overpaid taxes are offset on a later payroll that quarter or refunded by the IRS or the state.
  • Cancel. OnPay’s terms ask for 30 days’ written notice to end the service. Your returns and reports stay in your account afterward, and if the business is closing, Form 941 has a box to mark the last one as final.

The tax side

OnPay’s fees are a business expense. An S-corp deducts them on its own return, Form 1120-S, and a sole proprietor paying employees deducts them on Schedule C. Your salary is deductible to the S-corp and taxed on your W-2, and the company’s half of Social Security and Medicare is a business expense too. Our payroll taxes guide runs the numbers on a $60,000 salary.

The IRS says the employer stays ultimately responsible for its payroll taxes, even when a service makes the deposits. You can check each federal deposit yourself by enrolling in EFTPS, the Treasury’s payment system, as OnPay’s help center explains. If a deposit is ever missed, the IRS’s first bill is usually a CP161 notice.

FAQ

How much does OnPay cost for one person?

It’s $49 a month plus $6 per person paid, so $55 a month, or $660 a year, to pay just you. The bill after a month with no payroll is $49. The first month is free, and extra states and extra pay runs cost nothing more.

Does OnPay file my payroll taxes?

Yes. It deposits and files federal, state and local payroll taxes, including Forms 941, 940, W-2 and W-3, and it files the returns for quarters with no payroll. You sign Form 8655 at setup so it can file for you, and some states need you to give it access to your state tax account too.

Is OnPay good for an S-corp?

For paying yourself a salary, yes. You can run payroll monthly, quarterly or once a year, and its shareholder pay types put company-paid health insurance on your W-2 for income tax. It doesn’t file your S-corp election or suggest a salary. Here’s how a one-person S-corp works.

How long does OnPay direct deposit take?

Two or four business days, set by a risk review after you verify your bank account. With 2-day, you submit payroll by Wednesday night for a Friday payday, and with 4-day, by Monday night. OnPay may review it again after 6 months, if you ask.

Is OnPay legit?

OnPay is a payroll company based in Atlanta that says it has served clients for more than 30 years. It rates 4.8 out of 5 from 469 reviews on Capterra and 3.6 from 318 on Trustpilot as of October 2026.

Is OnPay cheaper than Gusto?

For one person in one state, they cost the same, $55 a month. In two states, OnPay stays at $55, while Gusto needs its Plus plan, $92 a month for one person. Gusto Solo adds help with the S-corp election and a salary suggestion.

Sources

Prices, plans and reviews checked October 25, 2026. OnPay changes its offers from time to time, so its pricing page has the current price. General education, not tax advice. Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure. It never changes what we recommend.