The short answer
You’ve written a few posts, a handful of readers say they’d pay for more, and now you’re choosing where the newsletter should live. beehiiv and Substack both cost nothing to start, so the real differences show up later: in what each one keeps when readers pay, and in how much of the audience is yours.
Is beehiiv better than Substack?
For most one-person businesses, yes. On its paid plans, beehiiv takes 0% of subscriptions, runs its own ad network and sends from your own domain. Substack suits writers who want to start charging with nothing up front: it’s free at any size but keeps 10% of what readers pay. At 1,000 subscribers, beehiiv costs less once readers pay you over $590 a month.
Card fees go to Stripe on both, so the real gap is Substack’s 10% against beehiiv’s monthly plan. Below, we compare the costs at each list size, who owns your list, the tools for growing and earning, and the tax side, using both companies’ pricing and help pages as of October 25, 2026. Our own newsletter runs on Kit, so we’ve compared these two on their published terms rather than daily use.
Check current pricing
beehiiv vs. Substack at a glance
Here’s how they line up for a list of 1,000 subscribers, billed monthly.
| beehiiv | Substack | |
|---|---|---|
| Free to start | Free plan, up to 2,500 subscribers | Free at any size |
| Paid subscriptions | Lite plan and up, $59/month; beehiiv keeps 0%, plus Stripe’s 2.9% + 30¢ | Any publication; Substack keeps 10%, plus Stripe’s 2.9% + 30¢ and 0.7% billing fee |
| Your own domain | Any paid plan, for the website and the address emails come from | $50 once, for the website; emails still come from substack.com |
| Ads and sponsors | Ad network on any paid plan; sponsor storefront on Pro | No ad network; sponsorship program from 100 paid subscribers |
| Growth tools | Free recommendations on every plan; paid recommendations and a referral program on Lite | Recommendations, Notes, the Substack app and subscriber referrals, all free |
| Automatic emails | 10 automations on Lite, unlimited on Pro | Welcome emails |
| Export your list | Any plan, as a CSV file | Any time, as a CSV file |
| Sales tax on subscriptions | Up to you, through Stripe Tax | Substack collects and pays it from December 1, 2026 |
Checked October 25, 2026 on beehiiv’s pricing page and Substack’s fee page. Paying beehiiv yearly saves up to 20%: Lite is then $49 a month at 1,000 subscribers.
What each one costs as your list grows
Substack charges nothing until readers pay you. From then on, it keeps 10% of every subscription payment. beehiiv works the other way around: a monthly plan fee, priced by the size of your list, and none of your subscription revenue.
Say you have 1,000 subscribers and 60 of them pay $8 a month. That’s $480 a month, and Substack keeps $48. beehiiv’s Lite plan costs $59 whatever you earn, so Substack comes out $11 ahead. Grow to 100 paying readers, or $800 a month, and it flips: Substack keeps $80 while beehiiv still costs $59.
1,000 subscribers · October 2026
What each one costs as paid subscriptions grow
Substack’s 10% of paid subscriptionsbeehiiv Lite: $59 a month, whatever you earn
Along the bottom: what paid subscribers pay you each month. beehiiv Lite billed monthly for up to 1,000 subscribers ($49 a month if paid yearly). Stripe’s card fees apply on both and are left out. Prices from beehiiv’s pricing page and Substack’s help center, checked October 25, 2026.
Over a year at $800 a month, that’s $960 to Substack against $708 for beehiiv, or $588 if you pay beehiiv yearly.
The crossover moves as your list grows, because beehiiv charges more for a bigger list. Here’s where it sits at each size.
| Subscribers | beehiiv Lite, monthly | Lite, paid yearly | beehiiv costs less above |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $59 | $49 a month | $590 a month |
| 2,500 | $79 | $69 a month | $790 a month |
| 5,000 | $109 | $95 a month | $1,090 a month |
| 10,000 | $139 | $119 a month | $1,390 a month |
The last column uses monthly billing. With yearly billing, the crossover drops to $490, $690, $950 and $1,190 a month. beehiiv bills a list between two sizes at the higher one, so 3,000 subscribers pay the 5,000 price.
A few other costs can shift the math, on both sides.
- App store fees on Substack. When a reader subscribes with an in-app purchaseA payment made inside a phone app and billed by Apple or Google, which keep a share as their fee, often 15% to 30%. in Substack’s iPhone app, Apple handles the payment and takes 15% to 30%, and Google takes 10% on Android. Substack’s own 10% is figured on your web price, and you can raise in-app prices to cover the store’s cut.
- Substack Boost. When it’s on, Substack can offer some readers a discount, such as 20% off a paid plan for a year, which lowers what each of those subscribers pays you. It can be switched off in settings.
- beehiiv’s other fees. beehiiv keeps 20% of paid recommendations, and $10 of each sponsorship you sell through its storefront.
- A custom domain. Substack charges $50 once. On beehiiv it comes with any paid plan, and the Free plan uses a beehiiv web address.
Who owns your list
On both, you do. Substack says you’ll always own your readers’ email addresses and can export them at any time. beehiiv exports your full subscriber list, with custom fields and stats, from its settings on every plan.
Paid subscribers are billed through your own Stripe account on both platforms, and that’s what lets them move with you. beehiiv’s import tool, for example, pulls paid subscribers from the Stripe account you used before and keeps their renewal dates, so nobody is billed twice.
Substack has three wrinkles worth knowing before you build there.
- Apple subscribers stay with Apple. Readers who pay in Substack’s iPhone app are billed by Apple, and Apple doesn’t hand those subscriptions to another platform. If you leave, you keep their email addresses, but they’d have to subscribe again.
- Followers aren’t subscribers. Someone who follows you on Substack sees your Notes in the app, but you don’t get their email address.
- Some readers live in the app. Substack’s app can deliver your posts as push notifications instead of email, so part of your audience may read you inside Substack rather than in their inbox.
beehiiv keeps more of the relationship under your own name. On any paid plan, your website can sit on your domain and emails go out from an address like hello@email.yoursite.com. Substack’s $50 domain covers the website, but emails still come from a substack.com address.
Our take: neither one traps you, since both let you leave with your list. If the newsletter is part of your business’s brand, beehiiv’s setup is closer to owning it outright.
Growing your list and earning from it
This is where the two differ most. Substack is built around readers finding you inside its network. beehiiv gives you more ways to earn, most of them on paid plans.
Substack: a built-in audience
Readers discover new writers through the Substack app, Notes (its social feed) and recommendations, where one writer suggests another to new subscribers. In February 2024, Substack said its recommendations and app drove 50% of all new subscriptions and 25% of new paid subscriptions on the platform. Its help center adds that a writer who recommends others is 3 times more likely to be recommended.
Earning outside subscriptions is limited. Substack has no ad network, and its sponsorship program, which matches writers with brands, is open only to Bestseller publications and those with at least 100 paid subscribers.
beehiiv: more ways to earn
beehiiv was built for newsletters that run like small media businesses, and it shows in the money tools.
- An ad network on any paid plan. beehiiv offers you sponsor ads from its marketplace, paid by the open or by the click. A $5 CPMCost per mille: what an advertiser pays for every 1,000 opens or views. A $5 CPM pays $5 for each 1,000 unique opens of your email. pays $5 for every 1,000 unique opens. Earnings land in your beehiiv Wallet on the 20th of the following month. beehiiv’s pricing page puts average ad earnings at $39 a month, which wouldn’t cover the $59 Lite plan by itself.
- Recommendations, free and paid. Free swaps with other newsletters work on every plan, the Free plan included. On paid plans you can also pay other newsletters for each verified subscriber they send you, or earn by recommending theirs.
- A referral program on Lite, where readers earn rewards for bringing in friends. Substack’s subscriber referrals are free.
- Digital products at 0%. You can sell a guide or a template from your beehiiv site with no beehiiv cut. Stripe’s fee still applies.
- Automations. Lite allows up to 10, like a welcome series that sends itself. On Substack, the automatic emails are welcome emails, one each for free, paid, founding and imported subscribers.
Our reader offer: sign up through our beehiiv link and you get a 14-day free trial plus 20% off your first 3 months on a paid plan. We earn a commission if you upgrade. Substack has no affiliate program, and the commission doesn’t change our pick.
The tax side of a paid newsletter
A newsletter that earns money is a business, and the IRS treats it like one, whichever platform it runs on.
- It’s business income, form or no form. Paid subscriptions, ad payouts, recommendation earnings and sponsorships all go on Schedule C, and the profit owes self-employment taxSocial Security and Medicare tax for people who work for themselves: 15.3% on 92.35% of your profit, on top of income tax. as well as income tax. Here’s how creator income is taxed.
- The 1099-KThe form payment apps and card processors send to report what you were paid through them. For 2026, apps and marketplaces send one over $20,000 and more than 200 payments; a traditional card merchant account reports card payments at any amount. shows your gross. On both platforms, subscriptions are paid into your own Stripe account, and Stripe sends a 1099-K for 2026 if you’re paid more than $20,000 across more than 200 payments. Substack’s help center notes the form shows your total gross volume, including the fees Substack and Stripe kept. On beehiiv, each ad report downloads as a PDF with the payout amount and date, and the Wallet exports every transaction to a CSV file.
- The fees are business expenses. beehiiv’s plan, Substack’s 10%, Stripe’s fees and Substack’s $50 domain all come off your income before tax.
- Sales tax depends on the state. Many states tax digital subscriptions. From December 1, 2026, Substack calculates, collects and pays sales tax or VAT on paid subscriptions for you, at no extra cost, and for U.S. writers it’s added at checkout on top of your price. beehiiv doesn’t collect it for you: its help center points you to Stripe Tax in your own Stripe account, which charges 0.5% per transaction where you’re registered. Here’s how sales tax works for a business of one.
Which one fits your business
It comes down to whether the newsletter is mainly writing that readers pay for, or part of a business you’re building under your own name.
- Choose beehiiv if you want the newsletter on your own domain, plan to earn from ads or sponsors, want automations, or expect paid subscriptions to pass about $590 a month. Plan on the $59 Lite plan, since the Free plan doesn’t include paid subscriptions. See beehiiv’s plans and free trial.
- Choose Substack if you want to charge readers with nothing up front, you’re happy with Substack’s design and email address, and you’d like its app and recommendations to help readers find you. Start on Substack.
- Look at Kit too if the newsletter is mainly a way to stay in touch with clients or sell a product. Its free plan holds up to 10,000 subscribers. Kit vs. beehiiv compares the two plan by plan, and our best newsletter platform guide covers five options.
Our take: for a business of one, beehiiv is the stronger long-term home, and Substack is a fine, free place to find out whether people will pay to read you. Starting on Substack doesn’t lock you in, since beehiiv’s importer brings over your posts, your list and your card-paying subscribers.
FAQ
Is beehiiv cheaper than Substack?
It depends on what readers pay you. Substack is free until then and keeps 10% after. At 1,000 subscribers, beehiiv’s Lite plan ($59 a month) costs less once paid subscriptions bring in more than $590 a month.
Can I move from Substack to beehiiv?
Yes. beehiiv imports your Substack posts and subscriber list, and its paid subscriber import moves card-paying subscribers through your Stripe account, keeping their renewal dates. Readers who subscribed through Apple in Substack’s iPhone app can’t be moved, so they’d need to subscribe again.
Does Substack own my email list?
No. Substack says you’ll always own your readers’ email addresses and can export them at any time. Followers are different: someone who only follows you on Substack doesn’t give you their email address.
Can I use my own domain?
On beehiiv, any paid plan lets you use your domain for the website and for the address emails come from. On Substack, a one-time $50 connects your domain to the website, but emails still come from a substack.com address.
Does beehiiv take a cut of paid subscriptions?
No. beehiiv takes 0% of paid subscriptions and digital product sales, and Stripe’s 2.9% + 30¢ per payment still applies. beehiiv does keep 20% of paid recommendations and $10 of each sponsorship sold through its storefront.
Which is better for a free newsletter?
Both cost nothing. Substack is free at any size, while beehiiv’s free plan holds up to 2,500 subscribers, without a custom domain. If you never plan to charge, Kit’s free plan, up to 10,000 subscribers, is worth a look too.
Do I need a business address to send a newsletter?
Yes, on both. U.S. law requires a valid postal address in every marketing email, and Stripe can show it on subscribers’ receipts too. A P.O. box or a registered private mailbox works if you’d rather not show your home address. Here’s how to set one up.
Sources
- beehiiv pricing
- beehiiv: Ad Network FAQ
- beehiiv: Recommendations Network FAQ
- beehiiv: Direct sponsorship storefront
- beehiiv: Using the beehiiv Wallet
- beehiiv: Exporting subscriber data
- beehiiv: How to import paid subscribers
- beehiiv: How to migrate from Substack
- beehiiv: Using a custom domain
- beehiiv: Paid subscription settings and Stripe Tax
- Substack: How much does Substack cost?
- Substack: Setting up a custom domain
- Substack: Paying in the iOS app
- Substack: Paying in the Android app
- Substack: How payouts work
- Substack: Exporting your email list
- Substack: Your email list and app readers
- Substack: What is following?
- Substack: Welcome emails
- Substack: Creator Kits and sponsorships
- Substack: How do I get featured?
- Substack: The recommendations network (February 2024)
- Substack: Upcoming changes to tax
- Substack: Filing taxes on Substack income
- Stripe Tax pricing
- IRS: Form 1099-K threshold reverts to $20,000
- FTC: CAN-SPAM Act compliance guide
Prices and terms checked October 25, 2026 and change often; confirm on each company’s site before you sign up. General education, not legal or tax advice. Our picks are never ranked by payment from the companies listed.